A corporate VPN of your own, or a consumer VPN service?
Many teams start with a consumer VPN subscription for each developer. It works, until it does not. Here is where the two approaches differ for AI coding tools, and when each one is the right choice.
What a consumer VPN is built for
A consumer VPN service protects one person. It offers many locations, a single app and a simple switch. That is a useful job, and most consumer services do it well.
It was not designed for a company that wants every developer on the same stable route to its AI tools, with an administrator who can see what is happening.
Where it falls short for a team
Strangers share your address
The exit address of most consumer services is used by many other people at once. Whatever they do from it, the AI service sees one address with a mixed history.
A company you did not choose
By default, all of the device’s traffic goes through a provider you picked for convenience, not as the place your code and prompts should travel through.
Nobody sees the fleet
Consumer apps are built for one person, so they usually give no team-wide view of which developer is connected, which client version runs where, or what changed and when.
One subscription per person
Each seat is set up separately, and it is easy to lose track of who still has one.
The comparison
| Guard Tun | Consumer VPN | |
|---|---|---|
| Runs on your servers | yes | no |
| An exit address only your company uses | yes | no |
| Only AI traffic in the tunnel | yes | no |
| AI traffic stops if the tunnel drops | yes | partly |
| Console with devices, usage and audit log | yes | partly |
| Clients update themselves | yes | yes |
Many consumer apps can block the whole device when the tunnel drops, which is why that row is only partly covered. Guard Tun does it for the listed AI domains and leaves the rest of the machine alone. The same goes for the console row: consumer apps are built for one person, so a team-wide view is usually missing, although some business plans add a dashboard.
When a consumer VPN is still the right call
For one person, for personal use, or for travel on public Wi-Fi, a consumer VPN is simple and sensible. If you have no need for a shared exit, a console or control over where the traffic goes, you do not need to run anything yourself.
The balance shifts when several developers depend on the same AI tools every day, and when someone has to answer for how that connection is set up.
Moving a team over
- Start a pilot on one of your servers with a few developers.
- Give each developer a profile link. The client installs from it and keeps itself up to date.
- Leave the old subscriptions running until the pilot is accepted, then retire them.
Questions
Isn't a consumer VPN cheaper?
Per seat it may well be. The difference is not the price of a subscription but who owns the exit address and who can see what. With a consumer service the exit is shared and the provider sits in the path of your traffic. With a VPN on your own servers the exit is yours and the administrator has a console.
Is our traffic visible to you?
No. The nodes and the console run on your servers, so the traffic goes from the developer’s device to your node and from there to the AI service. It does not pass through infrastructure of ours.
Can developers keep their personal VPN?
The client checks the machine and names another VPN that conflicts with it, and the operator gets a hint about what to fix. What to do about it is the administrator’s decision.
Does it slow down the rest of the internet?
No. Only the listed domains (Anthropic, Cursor, OpenAI, JetBrains and whatever the administrator adds) go through the tunnel. Video calls, package mirrors and the rest of the web go direct.
Read next
- Against Tailscale and ZeroTier Mesh networks join machines to each other. See how that differs from a controlled way out.
- Against a hand-rolled VPN What comes after the first evening of setting up a server yourself.
- Self-hosted Nodes and console on your own servers, with the address the AI services see being yours.
Request a demo or a pilot
Tell us about your team, and we will come back with a time for a call and a plan for a pilot.